Wednesday 26 August 2009

Advantage of Writing Craft Books

I am participating in Absolute Write Blog Chain again this month. Corrine asked me this question: On your blog, you mention reading quite a few craft books. What have you found useful in writing craft books to apply to your own work? Have they been more or less useful than writing classes or critique groups, if you've been involved in these? I have found craft books very useful. In fact, it has been my main method for acquiring knowledge of techniques and methods. I read many blogs and articles of course, but they almost always discuss merely the surface of things, whereas books go indepth. I have never been involved in a critique group, and have only attended short, day workshops for beginners. The workshops were fun and good to get creative juices flowing, but not useful. Main reason being, they were aimed for beginners, and I found that by beginner a lot of other writers present simply lacked confidence to write. I don't have that problem. I also feel that unless the workshops/critique groups are led by regularly published authors, there isn't much point. It's not to say that other people - beginner writers and readers - can't give me good advice, but the problem is that there is so much conflicting advice, it's hard to determine who is right. At least if it's coming from a regularly published author, you know for sure that they know what they are talking about. That's where writing craft books are advantageous. I don't just read all random books. I look at them carefully and determine if they have use for me. I also look at who or what they come from. For example, I own several writing book from Writers Digest Publishing. Writers Digest is a reputed, professional enterprise, and so I have faith in their books. Now, I am not saying that I do every exercise these books tells me to. In fact, for the most part I haven't done any. But I absorb what they say, and from that, I learn more about a good book is put together, so that when I am looking at my own manuscript, I am more aware of things that should be what's missing. Before, I used to look at my first draft, and know that it wasn't good enough but without any clue as to how to fix things. But now, because I have been studying craft books, I know more about the ingredients. When you know what's supposed to be in a recipe, you can play around and mix it to your own taste. So in conclusion then - good writing books that give you solid (ideally step-by-step) direction for how to do something are definitely useful. I don't much go for inspirational type books that just talk about writing rituals and getting inspiration and stuff, because I don't need that. I don't need anyone to tell me that I can be a writer. All I want is knowledge of craft that could only come from experience or from learning. Question for Forbidden Snowflake You started your blog to record your journey to improve self-discipline and write 100K words. Has having a blog to record your progress helped you? What do you do to motivate yourself to write? And what is it that demotivates you when you can't write?

11 comments:

  1. I agree with your take on craft books. Gotta choose them based on what you need, and also learn to sort between what you want/your work needs and what you don't really want/your work doesn't need. Too much conflicting stuff in there, so take what makes your work better and have the confidence to make that choice. :)

    Interesting to hear your take on day-long beginner's writing classes, also. :)

    ReplyDelete
  2. I agree with your comments about advice from published authors being the most valuable. It does seem that the best way to get that is through books on the craft. You'll have to do a post on the books you're working through now, give us all a little review of them maybe?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Sputnisa,
    thanks for your comment. Yes, I do believe all the conflicting views do make it difficult when you are just trying to get your head around everything.

    Jamie,
    Yes, review of the craft books seems a good idea. I will plan that for one of the future posts. It will be interesting to get people's comments on what they have found useful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Great post. I agree that craft books can help, but I'd add that writers should make sure they get ones that are current with the industry.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Tara,

    Yes for the most part I do agree though I would say there are few exceptions. For example, Stephen King's On Writing or Orson Scott Card's How to Write SF and Fantasy are not latest, but because both those writers are so good at what they do that their advice transcends time. In King's case, it's not much of an advice anyway, but even so, just his story his inspiring.

    Though for the most part, I do prefer recent stuff.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Your advice sounds similar to my advice: see what others have to say, and adapt it to yourself.

    ReplyDelete
  7. The best exercise I've done is to examine one of my favorite novels. I took it apart, wrote an outline as if it was my own novel, and plotted out the course of action, plus MC's journey. This took a full day, but at the end of it, I had a model for how to plot out a full novel with intertwined storylines. Best thing I've ever done to help me with my writing! PS. I second Jamie's suggestion to post a review of the books you're reading.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I wish I could find this kind of books in my local market. I do not have any access to buy ebooks through Internet. So, I have little idea about craft books on writing.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Cory,
    Dissecting a book is an excellent technique. In fact, that's one of the prominent advice I have read. Unfortunately, I haven't done that myself yet. I am too impatient to sit down and do that with someone else's story, but I must. I will give it a go eventually.

    Razib, what about ordering books online? I don't know what country you live in, but couldn't you perhaps order them from US/UK and have them delivered to your country?

    ReplyDelete
  10. Very interesting post. And I totally agree with Jamie's suggesting that you review some of these books. It will be interesting to see what has inspired you.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Thank you for your insight here! I'm like you in a few regards (not just in writing but in learning in general) and am glad to know I'm not unusual (as I've been told.) ;) Seems everyone believes you need another person to tell you right from wrong even if wrong is actually right. :)

    ReplyDelete